It's a familiar feeling. You open your app, see that your fund has done worse than a friend's fund, or worse than the "top funds" list, and you wonder if you picked the wrong one. Maybe you should switch? Sometimes that instinct is right. Often it isn't. Every fund goes through patches where it lags, even good ones. The trick is telling a temporary bad patch from a fund that has genuinely stopped doing its job. Here's a calm way to judge.
First, compare with the right thing
Comparing a large cap fund with a small cap fund is like comparing a car's mileage with a bike's. Different categories behave differently. Always compare your fund with two things: its own benchmark index, and other funds in the same category.
Our page on benchmarks explains what each fund is measured against, and our page on SEBI fund categories explains the groups.
Look at the right time period
One year is far too short to judge an equity fund. Markets favour different styles at different times. A fund can lag for a year or two and then do well for several years. Look at three, five and seven-year periods, and ideally at rolling returns, which show performance across many different starting points.
Our page on rolling returns explains why they're more reliable than a single number.
Check how it behaved in falls
Some funds lag in strong rising markets but fall less when markets crash. That can be a deliberate style, and many investors value it. Look at how your fund did during past falls compared with its peers. A fund that protects better on the way down may be worth keeping even if it rarely tops the charts.
Our page on maximum drawdown explains how to look at falls.
Signs of a temporary bad patch
- It lagged for a year or so, but has a good longer record.
- Its style, like value or large caps, is simply out of favour right now.
- The same fund manager and process are still in place.
- Similar funds with the same style are also lagging.
In these cases, patience is usually wiser than switching.
Signs of a real problem
- It has lagged its benchmark and most peers for three years or more.
- The fund manager changed and performance worsened afterwards.
- The fund has drifted from its stated style or category.
- Its risk has risen a lot without better returns.
- Costs are much higher than similar funds.
If several of these apply, it may be time to review seriously.
Don't chase last year's winner
Here's the trap. The fund at the top of this year's list is often there because its style had a great run, and switching into it after the run is exactly when you're most likely to catch the cooling-off that follows, which means you sell your fund just before its turn comes and buy the other just after its best days.
Buy high, sell low. Without meaning to.
Our post on why your friend's fund did better explains this pattern.
Check the costs
A higher expense ratio is a sure drag every year. If two funds are similar in every other way, the cheaper one has an advantage. Compare the expense ratio of your fund with others in its category.
Our page on expense ratio explains how costs affect returns.
Look at your own return, not just the fund's
Your personal return depends on when you invested. If you started a SIP just before a fall, your return may look poor even though the fund is fine. Check your XIRR alongside the fund's published returns.
Our page on XIRR explains how to read your own return, and our post on why your SIP is showing a loss covers the early years.
Check what the fund actually holds
Sometimes a fund looks poor because of a few big holdings that had a bad year. Read the fact sheet: are the top holdings sensible, is it concentrated in one sector, has it changed a lot recently? A fund with a sound portfolio going through a rough patch is different from one making questionable bets. Our page on the fund fact sheet explains what to look for.
Too many funds can hide the problem
If you hold six or eight funds, one weak performer can be hard to spot, and many of them may overlap anyway. Fewer, well-chosen funds are easier to review. Our post on how many funds you should own explains why.
Index funds as a yardstick
An index fund on the same benchmark is a useful reference point. If your actively managed fund has trailed a low-cost index fund for many years, after costs, it's worth asking whether the extra fee is earning its keep. Our page on active versus passive funds explains the trade-off.
Your goal hasn't changed
Before switching, remind yourself what the money is for and when you need it. If the goal is still many years away and the fund is reasonable, a short lag matters very little. If the goal is close, the bigger question may be whether the money should be in equity at all.
Keep the goal in view.
If you decide to switch
You don't have to sell everything at once. A gentle approach is to stop new SIPs into the old fund and start them in the new one, leaving existing units invested. This avoids exit loads and tax on the old units, and you can decide about them later.
If you do sell, check exit loads and tax first. We don't offer tax services, so ask a tax adviser for large amounts. Our page on switching mutual funds explains the options.
Review once a year, not every month
Checking performance every week creates anxiety and bad decisions. Once a year is enough. Write down why you chose each fund. At the yearly review, ask whether those reasons still hold.
Our page on reviewing your portfolio explains what to look at.
Write down why you chose the fund
When you first invest, note in one or two lines why you chose that fund: its category, style, manager or role in your plan. At review time, these notes are gold. If the reasons still hold, a weak year matters less. If they don't, you have a clear reason to change. It also stops you from switching on a whim after one bad month, which is when most regrettable switches happen.
A simple checklist
- Compare with the benchmark and same-category peers.
- Look at three to seven years, and rolling returns.
- Check how it behaved in falls.
- Check for manager changes, style drift and high costs.
- If switching, redirect SIPs first.
The bottom line
Lagging for a while doesn't make a fund bad. Judge it against the right benchmark, over the right period, and on how it behaves in falls. Switch only when the problems are real and lasting. Patience with good funds usually pays better than constant hopping.
If you're unsure whether one of your funds is underperforming, I'm happy to look at it with you. Myfolios is an AMFI-registered mutual fund distributor (ARN-145870) working from Indore since 2014. We're distributors, not investment advisers. Get in touch.